How Do You Know When to Pause an Argument?
Updated: 41 minutes ago
You were trying to talk about one thing.
You wanted more time together, or you were trying to explain why something they said bothered you.
At first, it was a conversation.
Then one of you got defensive, the other tried harder to explain, and the whole thing started to shift.
You could feel it.
Both of you were getting frustrated, and neither of you felt understood.
By the end, you may have been wondering how a conversation that started in one place ended up somewhere completely different.
You look back and wish you had stopped sooner.
Sometimes continuing the conversation doesn’t help
This can be especially hard if you’re the one who wants to get things resolved.
Stopping may feel risky. What if the conversation never gets picked back up? What if the thing that matters to you gets pushed aside again?
Your partner may be having a very different experience. They may already feel overwhelmed and be thinking, If we keep going, this is only going to get worse.
So you keep trying to explain.
They start pulling away.
And the more distance you feel, the harder you work to get through.
At some point, the conversation stops being about the original issue and starts becoming about what’s happening between the two of you in that moment.
That’s when taking a pause can help.
How do you know when an argument has reached that point?
You can often feel the shift.
You’ve said the same thing more than once, but it still doesn’t feel like your partner understands.
They’re explaining what they meant. You’re trying to explain how it affected you.
You may notice that you’re listening less and getting ready for what you want to say next.
Something from the past gets pulled in.
One of you gets more anxious and wants an answer now. The other feels more pressure and starts shutting down.
Before long, the conversation feels much bigger than whatever started it.
That’s usually the point when continuing to talk isn’t helping either of you feel more understood.
And when you finally stop, you may both feel hurt, misunderstood, or farther apart than you were before the conversation began.
Why do we keep getting pulled into the same pattern?
When the same kinds of conflicts keep happening, there’s usually more going on than whatever the two of you are arguing about.
One person feels dismissed, criticized, pressured, or alone.
They react.
Then their partner reacts to that reaction.
And pretty soon, neither of you is really responding to what started the conversation anymore.
You’re responding to each other.
To the defensiveness.
The silence.
The pushing.
The pulling away.
I call this a Cycle of Disconnect.
It can happen so quickly that you don’t really see it until later, when the conversation is over, and you’re both wondering how you got there again.
And if the conflict repair cycle keeps getting stuck in the conflict part, the repair never really happens.
That’s where couples can start to feel worn down by conversations that seem to go the same way every time.
Do we really need couples therapy for this?
You might wonder about couples therapy even when your relationship is strong in a lot of ways.
You enjoy each other. You laugh together. You make plans.
There’s plenty that still feels solid.
And then there are these conversations.
The ones that seem to go badly, no matter how many times you tell yourselves you’re going to handle them differently.
You’ve probably already talked about communicating better.
You’ve tried giving each other more space, waiting until you’re both in a better place to talk, or trying not to get so defensive.
And still, you get pulled back into the same pattern.
That doesn’t mean something is seriously wrong with your relationship.
It can simply mean the two of you are having trouble changing the pattern on your own.
That’s often when couples therapy can help.
It gives you a place to understand what’s happening between you and start communicating differently.
What happens in couples therapy when this pattern shows up?
When I work with couples, I’m listening to what you’re saying, but I’m also paying attention to what’s happening between you while you’re saying it.
I notice when the conversation starts to shift.
One of you gets defensive. The other explains more because they still don’t feel understood. Someone gets quiet.
And sometimes I’ll stop you right there.
Not because anyone did something wrong.
I help you recognize what just happened so you don't get pulled back into the familiar pattern.
I guide you through what’s happening underneath the conversation, not just the words being said.
At home, all of this can happen in a matter of seconds. In therapy, we have a chance to slow it down enough to notice it.
That’s a big part of how I work. I’m active in the conversation, and I’ll help you notice what's happening in real time, rather than only talking about it after an argument during a session.
Over time, that can help you understand each other differently and begin changing the way those conversations unfold.
Couples therapy doesn’t have to start with a crisis
Some couples come to therapy because something serious has happened.
Others come because they’re tired of the way certain conversations keep going.
Defensiveness may have become such a familiar part of your conflicts that you both know where the conversation is headed before you even start.
Or there may be a few subjects you’ve started avoiding because neither of you wants to end up in another argument.
That doesn’t mean your relationship is falling apart.
Things are happening between you that you haven’t been able to shift on your own.
And that’s enough to talk about in marriage counseling.
If this keeps happening between you
Maybe you’ve already had the conversation about having better conversations.
And still, you keep getting stuck.
That’s the kind of thing I help couples work through.
I offer online couples therapy in Connecticut and over 40 states, as I'm authorized through PSYPACT to do so.
If you’re wondering whether couples therapy could help the two of you communicate differently, you’re welcome to schedule a complimentary introductory call.
You can tell me a little about what’s been happening, ask any questions you have, and learn more about what working together would be like.
We can start there.
Not falling apart, but things still don’t feel quite right?
You don’t have to be ready to schedule a call.
Sometimes you just know something doesn't feel great.
You’re paying more attention to the way certain conversations go, how connected you feel afterward, or whether the two of you keep getting stuck in the same places.
If that’s where you are, my complimentary guide, When You’re Not Falling Apart, But Things Don’t Feel Okay, can help you sort through what you’ve been noticing.
It’s a place to start if you’re wondering whether what’s happening is something you want to keep watching, or something you’d like help with.
About Dr. Kristin Barnhart
Dr. Kristin Barnhart is a licensed psychologist in Connecticut, couples therapist, and founder of Breakthrough Counseling, LLC. She has been a licensed clinician for more than 30 years and provides online therapy for couples and individuals.
Dr. Barnhart works with committed couples in many stages of life, including dating, engaged, newly married, long-married, parenting, empty nest, and later-life couples. She specializes in helping couples improve communication, understand recurring conflict, repair trust, create healthier family boundaries, and rebuild emotional closeness.
She also provides online therapy for individuals navigating relationship conflict, anxiety, depression, stress, grief, and life transitions.
Her work is warm, practical, and tailored to your real life. She uses evidence-informed approaches, including cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), dialectical behavior therapy (DBT), solution-focused therapy, and strengths-based care. Christian-based support is available upon request.
Dr. Barnhart is authorized through PSYPACT to provide telepsychology in over 40 participating states.
To learn more about whether therapy may be a good fit, you’re invited to schedule a complimentary 15-minute introductory call by calling or texting 860-333-8773.
This article is for educational purposes and is not a substitute for therapy, diagnosis, or emergency care. I prioritize my clients’ privacy and never share their personal stories publicly. The experiences shared here are inspired by common relationship patterns and challenges I’ve observed.
Comments